Hi Jess! You'll want to set up the rules on the {[C-FIRST NAME]} field -- setting it to print only if the Standard Contact Field "Nickname" is blank. You'll then also put the Nickname field on the badge designer and stack the two on top of each other so that whichever field prints, it's in the same spot on the badge. I would suggest finding 2 registrants to use when testing/previewing the setup so you can preview and make sure that it's displaying correctly -- one registrant with the Nickname field filled in and one without.

------------------------------
Peggy Beach
Event Technology & Operations Manager
Equitable Financial Life Insurance Company
United States
------------------------------