Hi Nadia,
You've likely figured it out by now. If not hope this helps.
My experience is that once you copy an event and enter the event from your dashboard, the theme settings will open on the right-hand side. You just need to make your selections and then click the "finished" button at the bottom in order to be able to select the "settings" button.
#Classic-Creating/ManagingEvents
------------------------------
Nicole Phillips
Events Manager
Lummus TechnologyUnited States
------------------------------